Who should lead the Guam Education Board?
The board oversees the Guam Department of Education, the island’s largest government agency and public school system, which serves more than 23,000 students and employs more than 3,000 staff members.
Ron McNinch, the sole returning incumbent among the four candidates elected to the board, recently contacted Guam News Network (GNN), alleging that significant “wheeling and dealing” is underway over the board’s chairmanship. He proposed holding a debate for the position.
“There's a lot of wheeling and dealing going on right now for Education Chair. Why don't we have a full panel on board, so why not hold a debate,” McNinch said in an email to local media.
He suggested that representatives from outside organizations serve as judges.
“Let the Jury debate: I think the jury should be composed of: UOG Faculty, GCC Faculty, GNN member, PDN (Pacific Daily News) member, PostGuam member, Kandit News and one GDOE (Guam Department of Education) representative,” McNinch said. “The chair should be chosen from this group!”
Although the GEB typically has six elected seats, only four candidates ran in this year's election. According to results certified by the Guam Election Commission on Nov. 18, 2026, the candidates received the following votes:
John Ray Taitano II: 14,941 votes
Ron McNinch: 12,607 votes
Isaiah Aguon: 10,344 votes
Ronald Ayuyu: 8,264 votes
Taitano works for the Department of Public Health and Social Services. McNinch is a returning GEB member and a professor at the University of Guam.
Aguon is a special assistant to Legislative Secretary Sen. Sabrina Salas Matanane and a teacher at the Academy of Our Lady of Guam. Ayuyu is a former GEB chairperson and vice chairperson.
Several members of the 14th GEB will not return to the board. Maria Gutierrez and Peter Alecxis Ada did not seek re-election. Angel Sablan and current Vice Chairperson Mary Okada ran for higher office but were unsuccessful. Current Chairperson Judith Guthertz attempted to file her candidacy packet but did not obtain the required number of petition signatures.
The GEB consists of 12 members: six elected members serving two-year terms; three appointed members serving three-year terms; a nonvoting student member from the Island-wide Board of Governing Students; a nonvoting member appointed by the exclusive bargaining unit representing GDOE teachers and employees; and a nonvoting member appointed by the Mayors’ Council of Guam.
With the new members set to take their seats in January and two elected seats unfilled, Ayuyu said selecting a chairperson before the board is fully constituted would be a first.
Ayuyu disagreed with McNinch's proposal, saying the selection of board officers traditionally has been left to board members.
“Before selecting, they ask you, ‘Can you make a speech and tell us why you want to be a chair or vice chair at that moment of time when you're asking for votes, right?’ So that moment of time, you get a chance to speak. But to have GCC and UOG and DOE come in and give us a vote — on who makes the best speech or what — that's the first time,” Ayuyu said.
“We just have to wait for the board members to come in and decide that, because it's among the board that needs to elaborate how they want to select their chair and vice chair,” he said.
Ayuyu also questioned why outside organizations, including the University of Guam and Guam Community College, should be involved in evaluating candidates for the position.
“In the past they don't do that. They choose among themselves ... but for you to have another entity, another University of Guam or Guam Community college to come, you don't need to come in and rate us,” he said.
The former GEB chairperson said the board faced a similar situation during his previous term. He said the vacant seats were filled through gubernatorial appointments and argued that waiting for the new members would be fairer.
“Yeah, because it's unfair if we're suddenly going to be four of us. Four of us, we're going to be tied. How can we — you know what I mean? If it's going to be two-two, we're not going to go forward. So, it doesn't make sense for us to select a chair right away. I don't know why McNinch wants it to be a fast process, but it's not going to pass because I am not going to support it,” Ayuyu said.
“We have to have some courtesy and we have to have some respect for others that's going to be appointed. And that's what happened also in my time, when we were short board members,” he added.
Taitano believes debates and discussion are "always a great way to voice different perspectives and show that we want similar outcomes." But he did not support McNinch's proposal.
"However, the decision should be based on the law and rules governing selection of the GEB Chairperson," Taitano said.
GNN also requested response from Aguon regarding McNinch's proposal. Aguon declined to comment.
GEB Board Policy 105, which outlines the election of board officers, states that the election must take place during the January regular board meeting. Until an election is held and a chairperson is chosen, the incumbent chairperson presides over the board.
“A majority of the voting members for a particular candidate shall be necessary for election. Voting shall be by open ballot,” the policy, revised in January, states. “In the event of a vacancy in the Officers of the Board, the office shall be filled in the prescribed manner at the next regular meeting.”

